More Options
Return To Home Page


SOLID GOLD ADVERTISEMENT

“NO PRESCRIPTION IS MORE VALUABLE THAN KNOWLEDGE”

When Solid Gold introduced the first natural dog food into the U.S. in 1974, people were surprised that it didn't contain the usual ingredients found in other dog foods. We didn't use soybeans, wheat or corn - the number 1, 2 and 3 allergies of dogs that cause them to chew at the root of the tail or lick their feet. We don't use white rice, which is useless and missing 75% of its nutrients. We use amaranth, millet, barley and stone-ground brown rice.

We never use animal fat or poultry fat, which is rancid and may contribute to heart disease and cancer. We use canola oil and flaxseed oil, which are good for the immune system. Our flaxseed oil doesn't contain hexane; a chemical used by other flax oil companies. Our flaxseed oil helps the heart and is used by dogs with cardiomyopathy. Our flaxseed oil helps to reduce the incidence of epileptic seizures.

We never use sunflower oil. Cancer researchers use sunflower oil to induce cancer tumors in rats. Sunflower oil contains no omega 3, essential fatty acids, so necessary for development in unborn and young animals. Without omega 3's, skin problems occur.

Solid Gold Hund-N-Flocken never uses chicken. We use fish and lamb. All the Oriental dogs, Arctic dogs and dogs from England, Scotland, Ireland and water dogs were fed fish in their diets and sea vegetation. Our sea vegetation is our Sea Meal, which is always fed with our dog food. It works through the thymus and thyroid glands for the immune system.

Chickens are about the worst ingredient that could be put into dry dog food. In the 1970's, Dr. Virginia Livingston-Wheeler published her book, "Chicken; Cancer in Every Pet." She stated that cancer is almost 100% transmitted through the DNA and into the eggs. We don't use eggs in our dog food.

In the U.S., many poultry farms put ethoxyquin into the chicken's drinking water. Ethoxyquin is rated as a hazardous chemical by its manufacturer. It is supposed to make the egg yolk a brighter yellow, so you will think you are getting fresh eggs when you're not. Ethoxyquin doesn't have to be listed as an ingredient since the manufacturer didn't put it in the chickens.

In the U.S., many poultry farms put female growth hormones into chicken feed to produce big-breasted chickens for the fast food industry for chicken breast sandwiches. However, doctors are now seeing young boys developing breasts, small sexual organs and low sperm count. Young girls, as young as eight years of age, are experiencing their periods. Breast cancer in women is on the rise. There are ongoing investigations about the female growth hormones in people. What about the effect on our dogs?

The May 26, 1991 Atlantic Journal-Constitution Magazine warned about eating chicken. The magazine interviewed 84 Federal poultry inspectors in five states in the U.S. "Every week, they found millions of chickens leaking yellow pus, stained by green feces, and contaminated by harmful bacteria and marred by lung and heart infections and cancerous tumors. These chickens were shipped out for (human) consumption. The inspectors no longer eat chicken."

If the inspectors passed these for human consumption, what is the chicken in your dog food? Chicken by-products may be beak, feet and feathers. Digest is the full guts of the chicken - including any manure in the chicken when it is slaughtered.

In December 1997, China slaughtered a million and a half chickens. E. coli and Salmonella were found in chickens and ducks there. Some people died. Cooking chicken does not kill these diseases. It only deactivates them for a while. That is why at Thanksgiving, you are told to refrigerate the turkey after it is carved. Room temperature activates these diseases.


RESPONSE TO SOLID GOLD ADVERTISEMENT

"NO PRESCRIPTION IS MORE VALUABLE THAN KNOWLEDGE"

  1. There is also nothing more dangerous than incomplete knowledge or incorrect knowledge. This ad contains both.
  2. Solid Gold did not produce the "first natural dog food." Just calling something "natural" does not make it so. A natural food is the food, which matches the genetic expectation of the species. Amaranth, millet, barley and stone-ground brown rice, claimed ingredients in Solid Gold, are not natural foods for dogs or cats.
  3. Pet food grains are ground by steel hammer mills, not “stone” grinders. "Stone grinding" sounds quaint and more gentle than a hammer mill, but the net effect even if stone grinding was used (and a hammer mill is used carefully) would be the same.
  4. Food allergies are usually manifest in digestive disturbances, not "chewing the root of the tail," which is normally a sign of flea allergy dermatitis.
  5. Animal fat is the natural fat consumed by carnivores. If Solid Gold does not use it, how can they claim their food is "natural?"
  6. All animal fat is not "rancid." This would only be true if the fat were not properly stabilized. Highly unsaturated vegetable oils used in Solid Gold are much more susceptible to rancidity than animal fat. Flaxseed oil is so unstable it should only be eaten as freshly ground seeds or as a separate supplement in light impervious, nitrogen-flushed glass bottles kept in the freezer. Putting flaxseed oil in pet food paper bags, which are then stored on shelves, is a sure formula for rancidity, not the use of animal fats.
  7. Animal fat does not "contribute" to heart disease and cancer per se. This plays to popular misconceptions and the "low fat," "low cholesterol" fads, but does not reflect current science. There are nutritional factors within animal fat that are even cardioprotective and anticarcinogenic.
  8. Animal fats are "good for the immune system" too. They contain important essential fatty acids, fat-soluble vitamins and other fat-soluble nutrients valuable to carnivores not found in canola and flaxseed oils.
  9. Hexane is not used in the manufacture of nutritious flaxseed oils by most other companies. If it is used, it is then removed from the final product in good manufacturing methods. This is an attempt to create a boogieman where there is none.
  10. Cardiomyopathy in pets has been caused primarily by deficiency of the amino acid taurine, not flaxseed oil.
  11. Where is the epidemiological proof that the flaxseed oil in Solid Gold decreases the "incidence" of epilepsy? If the FDA sees this unsubstantiated claim (as well as most others in the ad) they will likely remove Solid Gold from the market.
  12. Sunflower oil does contain omega-3 fatty acids. It is also very high in omega-9 fatty acids (olive oil factors), is quite stable and has many health benefits. Attempting to paint sunflower oil and animal fat as the bad guys, and canola and flaxseed oils as the good guys, is overly simplistic and attempts to convince by creating or playing to ignorant prejudices. There are dangers and benefits to all food ingredients including every one used in Solid Gold products.
  13. How does Solid Gold "sea vegetation… work through the thymus and thyroid glands for the immune system?" No credible scientific explanation here or documentation, just a wild claim.
  14. Solid Gold "never" uses chicken because "Oriental," "Arctic," "dogs from England, Scotland, Ireland and water dogs" ate "fish and sea vegetation." How does this constitute a valid reason not to use chicken? Are "water dogs" and those from these countries somehow better than dogs from others (assuming the claim that they only eat fish and seaweed diets is true)?
  15. So chicken and eggs cause cancer in every pet. Simple enough. All an owner has to do is feed Solid Gold, which has fish and lamb and you never need to worry about cancer. This is Nobel Prize stuff.
  16. Ethoxyquin is an antioxidant used to preserve vitamins and prevent fat rancidity, not a drinking water additive. Ethoxyquin is not used to make the yolk "yellow." Ethoxyquin is not considered a hazardous chemical by the manufacturer. It is a food additive.
  17. "Female growth hormones" are not fed to most chickens. Chickens have not been proven to "cause" breast development in boys and early menses in girls. It is more likely this is caused by environmental pollutants, which have estrogenic activity.
  18. Horror tales can be told about what is seen in every meat processing plant - including those which process the "pus, cancerous, feces" - contaminated carcasses in the lamb and fish plants supplying ingredients for Solid Gold.
  19. Good Quality chicken by-products do not contain heads, feet and feathers. Are we to believe that Solid Gold contains prime fish fillets and racks of lamb? How could it, when such meats cost $5-$10 per pound fresh in the meat counter and Solid Gold costs nowhere near this, and even includes processing, packaging and shipping? It's a real good bet they use "by-products" too. The ad doesn't really get into what they use, just creates a chicken boogieman, which can only be vanquished by Solid Gold products.
  20. Digest may or may not contain the "full guts." So what if it does? The natural diet of carnivores is the "full guts" of their prey and that is often even the preferred first part of the meal. Is Solid Gold really advocating a natural diet or only interested in ad hominem arguments?
  21. E. coli and Salmonella can be found in any carcass, including fish and lamb. Heat does kill pathogenic organisms.
  22. True, turkeys should be refrigerated. Do fish and lamb not have to be refrigerated?

This ad demonstrates that anyone, regardless of credentials, skills, knowledge or motive, can go somewhere to find a pet food manufacturer to produce a food to introduce into the marketplace. Any imaginable nonsensical and irresponsible claim can be made to sell the product until the public wises up or regulatory agencies shut them down. The distortions and untruths in this ad should make any thinking person wonder what is in their product and whether it would be wise to feed products based on such error.

The irresponsible claims in this ad cast any manufacturer who is trying to make a more wholesome natural product in a bad light. It confirms in the consumer's mind the prejudice that "natural" must mean kooky and makes it that much more difficult for responsible progress to be made.

Nutrition is serious business, not a place for sensationalism, half-truths, factual errors, fads, prejudice and ignorance. The writer(s) of this ad should heed their own headline.

CAVEAT EMPTOR (Let the buyer beware).

 

.
 

Dear Friend,

Please go to http://www.wysong.net/rude.shtml to help understand our position on the issues you raise. Also, please review the "Don't Be Fooled" section carefully ( http://www.wysong.net/faqpets.shtml#fooled ).

Replies are embedded below with

 

I was just reading the controversy between you and Solid Gold. Actually Sea Kelp is proven to support the thyroid because it is high in iodine- look it up.

We do not dispute the nutritional merits of kelp. That was not our point.

And a good diet does fix many “allergy” problems because at LEAST 90% of diagnosed allergies are not allergies at all but a reaction because of a low immune system due to a poor and unbalanced diet usually containing too much grain and not enough meat protein and live enzymes.

We agree whole-heartedly. See Dr. Wysong's book, " The Truth About Pet Foods " chapter 16.

These afflictions may show in licking the feet, itching with no fleas present, ear infections, hair loss, over grooming an many other non intestinal afflictions.

True, but the claims by Solid Gold are untrue.

Also a dog with a strong immune system is not as susceptible to flea “infestations.

We most certainly agree. See above.

Thought you may be interested. I don't worry about the brand as much as the quality, HIGH MEAT CONTENT, live enzymes, and low on empty fillers (grains).

Grains are not necessarily used for "fillers." The starch they provide - or from potato, rice, tapioca or whatever - is necessary to extrude a dried form product. Wysong produces ALL meat products and was the first to incorporate active enzymes in processed foods. You must read the above material in the "Don't Be Fooled" section of our web site. Claims and labels can be misleading.

I am impressed with foods like Timberwolf, Canidae or EVO for a kibble

You have not stated why. Before you do, be sure to read the above material. Have you asked EVO, for example, about the claims that their canned and dry foods cooked at hundreds of degrees are the same thing as raw or how "no-grains" has any nutritional meaning when the starches of potato are used instead...see above link to "Raw deceptions."

but prefer my dogs eat real food like I do and they should. I don't believe any processed food or kibble can be that healthy.

Good for you! You are most certainly a thinking person and that is exactly the message Dr. Wysong has been teaching for the past 25 years. The above materials will certainly ring a bell of truth for you and give the scientific basis for why your good sense is correct.

Give us your address and we'll send you a free CD by Dr. Wysong and some samples to show you what can really be done with food when these principles come first.

I hope this information is of help to you. If I can be of further assistance, please feel free to contact me via e-mail.

It is always my pleasure to assist you.
Wishing you and yours the best of health,
Wysong Technical Staff

.

 

Dear Wysong:

"...You two companies (solid gold/ wysong), need to get over your feud It makes both companies look petty, and I should actually blow off both of you for such vicious attacks on each other. While sitting there eating your chicken nuggets, worrying about the % of fats going into your dogs, take a good look at what your dog chomps in during a fun run in the park...geesh, get over it, you both have excellent nutritional foods. Come on, rise above this putting down of each other to try to make yourselves look good...it doesn't work!!! People are out there buying Science Diet in droves because you all get them so confused about dog nutrition, while their vet has bags of Science Diet on his shelves, nice and handy, and he's been taught to support it.

You are trying to convince the wrong people. If your facts are all that you say they are, then get your butts out their and convince the Vets of America, because like it or not, other than a few gourmet dog food retailers out there....the Vet is the one who is going to sell your product. Hill's marketing strategy proves that. So guys, stop the battle, fire your marketing team and hire some of the Hill's people. Their product sucks, but you can't beat their marketing strategy.

Dear Friend,

Thank you for your letter.

There is no ongoing feud. Solid Gold publishes ads with fallacious and misleading information, we rebutted it. We post the information for its educational purposes for those who are interested in going beyond the surface of pet food marketing.

If you will explore our site in more detail you will see that the battle for health is not even really about who has the best food. That is not the purpose of our refuting erroneous information. The point of pet feeding - if health is the objective - is getting fresh natural food in variety to pets. All other issues bandied about in the pet food market are distractions simply designed to create sales and are pretty much irrelevant.

Moreover, if people are going to set themselves before the public as having special nutritional and health expertise by producing pet foods and then making health claims, then they should be expected to show competency with regard to the information put out to the public. Brain surgery should not be trusted to a plumber, and nutrition (a very complicated and serious health matter), should not be trusted to mere marketers pushing products based upon myths. See Don't Be Fooled http://www.wysong.net/faqpets.shtml#fooled .

We agree that veterinarians in the main have been misled. We have been trying to correct that for 25 years. Presently there are over 300 Wysong veterinary Clinical Consultants, so we are slowly making inroads .

.
"Your website finally let me read your Solid Gold article. What was that person so upset about? Everything you write is true. I quit using Solid Gold years ago when my dogs developed persistent allergies while being fed the various blends of Solid Gold dog food. I quit using it and have never gone back."

I just came across your web site and was floored at the hostile way the makers of Wysong lashed out at the producers of solid gold dog food, gees, there was no need for such sarcasm, just state the facts and your theories, do a comparison of the two products and be done with it. We are all smart enough to draw our own conclusions.

Thank you for your thoughts. Our objective is to help people achieve health for themselves and their animals. When we see ideas promoted that are grossly in error and mislead people away from that objective it is difficult to be diplomatic. Critiques of pet food manufacturers on our site are to be used as a learning tool by readers, not to be taken as an ‘our product is better than their product' debate. Try to understand the issues raised and why we say what we do so that you will better be able to evaluate health claims and products.
 
 

Apperon vs Wysong
Innova/Natura vs Wysong
Pet Promise
Whole Dog Journal vs Wysong
The Honest Kitchen
"100% human grade food."
Solid Gold vs Wysong
The Wysong Critique of the Internet
“Rate Your Dog Food” List
Nature's Logic
Nature's Variety

Copyright © 2008 by Wysong Corporation. This information may not be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means,
electronic or mechanical, without express written permission of the copyright owner, Wysong Corporation.

Address: 7550 Eastman Avenue, Midland, MI  48642  •  Phone: (989) 631-0009  •  Ordering: (800) 748-0188